A friend of mine is really into the so-called "9/11 truth movement," which posits that there is a big government conspiracy behind the 9/11 attacks, and that it wasn't really done by Muslim terrorists. Naturally, I was skeptical. He asked me what the terrorists motivation was for the attacks. I began to answer confidently: "They hate us for our freedom." But even before I finished answering, I realized that it was a totally ludicrous, absurd thing to say, and that it certainly wasn't true, and that--at best--it was wild, improbable speculation.
And then, the more I thought about it, I started to think about the Patriot Act, and the warrantless wiretapping, and the secret CIA prisons, and the prisoners we've been holding for half a decade now without charges, the insistence upon not outlawing torture against unconvicted and uncharged suspects, the re-classification of decades-old unclassified documents, and the new proposed rules allowing conviction of suspects without having the opportunity to confront the evidence against them.